Savings on fuel, breakdowns and pollution.  DEMONSTRATED!

RB-1 PROFITABILITY  STUDY IN POWER PLANTS
AFTER USING ADDITIVE
“rb bertomeu” beco F1/ASF IN DIESEL
ENGINES RUNNING ON HEAVY FUEL OIL

Date                 :     November 2001 - Updated  January 2017

Content: A- Experimental data to be used in the calculation
  B- Bases of the experimental data
  C- Profits verification time

A-    EXPERIMENTAL  DATA  TO  BE  USED  IN  THE CALCULATION


 The following data to be used in the calculation have been gathered from the experience accumulated by rb bertomeu S.L. in power plants with Diesel engines running on heavy fuel oil and it is fully guaranteed that they are obtainable by using the additive “rb bertomeu” beco F1/ASF and following the specified dosing and procedures, regardless of the type of Diesel engine considered.

 

When calculating the profitability achievable with the adoption of the additive “rb bertomeu” beco F1/ASF, according to the particular power plant one should apply the increases or reductions specified to the historical data recorded when the engines were in operation without the additive treatment. 



  1-1 Increase in normal TBO for maintenance of exhaust valves +  50 %  minimum
  1-2 Increase in the normal operational life of valves (due to corrosion): +  100 %  minimum
  1-3 Reduction in valve blowouts in normal operation   80 %  media
  1-4 Increase in normal TBO for cleaning turbos +   50 %  minimum
  1-5 Increase in the normal operational life of turbos (due to corrosion) +  100 %  minimum
  1-6 Reduction in fuel consumption per kWhe, due to better combustion 1,56 %  average
  1-7-1 Reduction of fuel consumption per kWhe , due to lesser wear of injection equipment 0,9 %  average
  1-7-2 Reduction of fuel consumption per kWhe , due to fuel sludge reduction 0,45 %  average
  1-7-3 Reduction of fuel consumption per kWhe , due to lesser incrustations in the turbo compressors 0,19 %  average
  1-8-1 Reduction of fuel oil sludge to be treated or handled 70 %  average
  1-8-2 Reduction of fuel oil sludge
Reduction of lubricating oil sludge
54,8 %
26,8 %
  1-8-3 Reduction of consumed fuel oil due to lesser sludge production (Kg/T) 5,80 Kg.
  1-8-4 Savings due to a lower volume of sludge to be recycled (sludge recycling cost: 110 €/T) 0,638 €/T of consumed fuel oil
  1-9 Reduction in downtime for maintenance 30 %  minimum
  1-10 Service Factor increase as a result of less downtime due to breakdowns and scheduled overhauls.. To be calculated for each engine or plant.

                                                                                                                         

 

After evaluating all the previous points, the Savings achieved expressed in Euros per MWhe produced, results in a Profit of 2.19 Euros/MWhe produced
(for an average consumption of fuel oil of 210 Kg/MWhe and a fuel oil price of 364 €/T.    January/2017)

 

 

PROFIT   =   SAVING   -   COST OF ADDITIVE “rb bertomeu” beco F1/ASF

 

MINIMUM  PROFIT    =     2.19   Euro/MWhe

 

 

 

B-    BASES OF THE EXPERIMENTAL DATA

 

B-1  REDUCTION  IN CORROSION ON EXHAUST VALVES [ A-1-1, A-1-2 and A-1-3 ]

 

One of the reasons for the high profitability of the use of the additive “rb bertomeu” beco F1/ASF is undoubtedly the increase in the lifespan of the exhaust valves of the engines by neutralising the corrosion. This provides great savings on the replacement of valves, in the labour costs of valve overhauls and in stoppages caused by valve blowouts, as well as an increase in the time between overhauls for valves (TBO), in relation to normal maintenance schedules.


For more information, see "Bulletin No. 7: Doubling the operational life of exhaust valves by using additive treatment for fuel oil.".


  

Regarding the increased TBO of the exhaust valves in May 2002, a long-term test was performed in a BV-16M Deutz 640 kW engine 6500. Such a test was jointly controlled by EWCAR, owner of the engine, Deutz Iberia-Deutz Ag, manufacturer thereof and "rb bertomeu", fuel oil additive manufacturer.

It proved to be possible to increase the TBO of the valves from 3,000 hours (recommended by the engine manufacturer) to 6,000 hours (an increase of 100%!).

For more information, see "Technical study RB-13: Energyworks-carballo extension of the lifespan of exhaust valves up to doubling TBO".


Notably, since, until today, the company EWCAR-EnergyWorks Carballo has not stopped using the additive as can be seen in reference letters that you can read here, having increased TBO valves up to 7,200 hours (140%!).

 

More information in "Bulletin No. 16: Exhaust valves in large engines operated with heavy fuel oil. Doubling the TBO for general overhauls.."

 

The fact that the anti-corrosion effects are able to be extrapolated for any type of engine is widely accepted on the grounds of the following key points:

 

B-1-1       When fuel oil is burned in a Diesel engine corrosion takes place, mainly on the exhaust valves, due to chemical attack on the alloy by compounds formed from impurities contained in the fuel oil, principally Vanadium, Sodium and Sulphur, while other metallic impurities are involved to a lesser extent. These compounds, at the high temperatures to which the exhaust valves are subjected (in excess of 800º C during combustion and 350-400º C in the exhaust gases) are inevitably corrosive. Some Sodium Vanadates are especially corrosive, being in a liquid state at temperatures as low as 340-350ºC.

Document RB-26 Corrosion linked to Vanadium compounds

 

B-1-2       Chemical corrosion is aggravated by the thermal fatigue to which a valve is subjected in the case of inappropriate operation, design or assembly. This can cause changes in the structure of the metal, making it more fragile, and liable to chemical attack from the corrosive compounds detailed above.

 

B-1-3       In order to prevent an excessively fast rate of corrosion on valves, state-of-the-art alloys are employed in the design of valves, which have been adopted by the majority of manufacturers as a fundamental factor to reduce the problem of corrosion. In spite of this, the problem has not been completely resolved and new designs and materials are continually being developed.

 

B-1-4       In addition to the type of material or alloy used in the construction of the valves, the rate of corrosion depends on the overall engine design and on the desing of valves themselves. In certain designs, several manufacturers resort to installing exhaust valves with greatly thickened material in the area of the seats, and thereby, with corrosion occurring at a certain rate, the life of the valves is prolonged.

 

B-1-5       The application of an appropriate anti-corrosion treatment, as it is the additive “rb bertomeu”, reduces chemical corrosion on the valves to a minimum, for any given engine design, type of valve and component material.

Estudio: RB-12 Magnessium as a solution for the corrosion problems derived from the combustion of heavy fuel oil.


Assuming that the engine is well designed, its valves are made of suitable material, and its mechanical assembly is faultless and that the engine is run in suitable conditions, the operational life of the valves depends on:

 

-         Manufacturing defects of the exhaust valves, which are a main factor in the rate of valve blowouts.

-         The onset, in the long term, of thermal and/or mechanical fatigue.

-         Chemical corrosion due to impurities in the fuel oil, which is a factor in the general corrosion of the seats and the rate of blowouts due to thermal stress and small defects acquired.

 

More information in "Bulletin No. 26: Typical anomalies occurring on the exhaust valves of diesel engines at general overhauls.".

IMPORTANT NOTE: The treatment of the fuel oil with “rb bertomeu” beco F1/ASF does not prevent the blowout or failure of an exhaust valve with manufacturing defects nor the various types of long-term fatigue. However, it does neutralise the chemical corrosion that reduces its operational life.

 

 

     B-2  REDUCTION IN CORROSION AND INCRUSTED RESIDUES ON TURBOS [A-1-4, A-1-5 y A-1-7-3]

 

The reduction in the level of corrosion and incrusted residues achieved, both on exhaust valves and Turbos and other parts of the exhaust gas circuit (fundamentally boiler heat exchangers) , is thanks to the additive "rb bertomeu" beco F1/ASF that raises the melting point of these residues.

 

With this effect, the corrosive salts formed during combustion of fuel oil are no longer in a liquid state or partially melted at temperatures as low as 330-350 ºC , as their melting points are increased to temperatures in excess of 1,200 ºC. Therefore, as the salts are only present in a solid state at the temperature of the gases in turbos and the rest of the exhaust gas circuit (320-400º C), their corrosiveness as well as their adherence to metallic surfaces is significantly reduced, and they are carried along with the gases. This prevents the usual problems that arise when no treatment is used.


Logically, should be considered that decreasing fouling in the turbochargers and exhaust gas circuit, has a favorable effect on reducing fuel consumption, in our case, a 0.19% savings in fuel oil. See document "RB-3 Reduced fuel oil consumption in power plants with diesel engines using the additive “rb bertomeu” beco F1/ASF"

 

It can easily be appreciated and demonstrated by experimental data that the rate of incrustation of the residues with a high melting point on the metallic parts of the circuit is much less than that of the residues with a low melting point. Given that the formation of residues during the combustion of fuel oil is inevitable, the modifying effect of the additive “rb bertomeu” beco F1/ASF derives from a significant reduction in incrusted residues and the consequent reduction in the need for their removal.

 

In the case of Turbos, there is an increase in the time interval allowed between stoppages for cleaning of between 50% and 100% on the normal interval, depending on the type of turbo and quality of the fuel oil. 

 

Although the rate of corrosion is much less than on the exhaust valves, the action of the additive “rb bertomeu” achieves a reduction in corrosion, such that it doubles the time taken for corrosion to appear on any of the components of the turbo (rotor, housing, etc.). There is experimental verification for the estimation of the onset of problems caused by corrosion on Turbos (when some of the component parts begin to need replacing), with and without the additive “rb bertomeu”, as follows:

 

a) WITHOUT using  “rb bertomeu” beco F1/ASF  :  From 10,000 to 16,000 Hours

b) WITH the additive “rb bertomeu” beco F1/ASF :  Over 40,000 Hours

 

For more information please read "Bulletin No. 9: Turbo-compressors in Diesel engines running on heavy fuel oil. How to increase its operational life and cleaning TBO"


 

B-3 REDUCTION IN FUEL CONSUMPTION [A-1-6]

 

The second most important reason for the high profitability of the use of the additive “rb bertomeu” is undoubtedly the reduction in fuel consumption per unit of energy produced by the engine. In the case of fuel oil, this reduction in consumption, (as has been amply checked) is brought about by the action of the additive prior to combustion, from the storage tanks to the point of injection.

 

The document RB-28 Actions and benefits of “rb bertomeu” heavy fuel oil additives, details the action of the additive "rb bertomeu" on the fuel oil, promoting the disintegration and dispersion of solids during storage and improved atomisation of the fuel at the point of injection into the combustion chamber of the engine. You can also read the Bulletin No. 4: "The fuel oil treatment reduces the consumption in large engines operated with heavy fuel oil.", when the fuel oil is treated with the addtive "rb bertomeu" beco F1/ASF.

 

Essentially, the total saving in consumption results from a combination of three main factors, uniquely provided by the action of the additive “rb bertomeu”:

 

B-3-1       REDUCED FUEL OIL SLUDGE [A-1-7-2, A-1-8-1, A-1-8-2, A-1-8-3 y A-1-8-4)

The action of the additive “rb bertomeu” in the storage tanks, disintegrating the existing sludge and emulsifying it in the fuel, while preventing sludge re-forming over time, reduces the quantity of organic sludge that is decanted in the tanks and removed by the fuel purifiers. This organic sludge which is not removed is then actually used as fuel, whereas without the additive it is eliminated and fuel consumption is increased.

 

At the same time, any costs of removal or treatment of sludge in plants (performed internally or by authorised contractors) are reduced in the same proportion as the percentage of reduction of sludge obtained from the treatment with “rb bertomeu”. The sludge reduction represents a decrease of 5.80 Kg/T of consumed fuel oil. Such a value means a reduction of 0.638 €/T of consumed fuel oil because of a lower sludge removal cost (prices in November 2015).


For more information, see "Bulletin No. 3: "Reducing the formation of fuel oil sludge cuts fuel consumption, means reducing operating costs."

 

B-3-2       IMPROVED ATOMIZATION OF THE HEAVY FUEL OIL [A-1-6]

The efficient surfactants contained in the additive work to achieve improved atomisation of the fuel oil in the combustion chamber with the same temperature, pressure and atomising components.  This improved atomisation provides more thorough combustion in the combustion chamber by optimising the fuel-air mixture, thereby achieving greater conversion of the calorific value of the fuel and, consequently, reduced consumption per unit of energy produced by combustion in the engine’s combustion chamber.

 

In addition to checking consumption, the evidence of improved combustion is easily demonstrated by the following:

-       The absence of black smoke composed of unburned particles

-         Reduction in CO in exhaust gases

-         Reduction in the opacity of exhaust gases (reduction by approximately 2 points on the Bacharach scale)

More information in "Bulletin No. 27: Statistical data on the analysis of combustion gases in power plants with Diesel engines running on heavy fuel oil."

The following letters of reference from some customers, certify what has been said (in Spanish):

- Letter Cogemansa

- Letter Intasa

- Letter Olcesa

- Letter Coosur

- Letter Paquito

- Other letters of reference here.

 

 

B-3-3       CONSERVATION OF THE ATOMISATION QUALITY [A-1-7-1]

It is widely accepted by engine manufacturers that fuel consumption increases as the injection components suffer ageing and wear, eventually using up to 3% more fuel towards the end of the operational life of the components in comparison with newly-installed ones.

Sufficiently extensive checking will demonstrate that the additive “rb bertomeu” is effective in neutralising the effects of wear on the injection components and prolonging their operational life. This delays the gradual onset of the increase in consumption, something inevitable without the use of the additive “rb bertomeu”, providing direct saving which often goes unnoticed or is not calculated    because    it    is    assumed    that    there    would    not    be    a    noticleable    increase   in   fuel   consumption    without the use of the additive "rb bertomeu" beco F1/ASF.

 

In some tests carried out in power plants with Diesel engines runnig on heavy fuel oil, reduction of fuel consumption arounf  0.9–1.2%, due to above explained concept, have been detected.

The following letters of reference endorse what has been said:


- Letter Boinersa

- Letter Cogemansa

- Letter Artabra

- Letter Paquito

- Letter Olcesa

- Letter Coosur

- Letter Coren

- Other letters of reference here.



B-4       IMPROVING THE SERVICE FACTOR [A-1-9 y A-1-10]


Reduction of downtime due to overhauls: 30% minimum


Increase of the Service Factor as a result of less downtimes because of breakdowns and scheduled overlauls.

 

Next you can find some letters of reference that certify this section's data.


Letter Ufefys (26/06/2015)
Letter Ufefys (30/01/2001)
Letter Intasa(20/01/2001)
Letter Boinesa (10/01/2001)
Letter Cogeman (10/01/2001)

Adding all the causes of consumption reduction describen in the past sections, represents a global saving of 3,1% in fuel oil consumption.

When we calculate our economical estimations, we take a conservative approach and only apply 2,4% in fuel oil saving.

 

PROFIT   =   SAVINGS   -   COST OF THE ADDITIVE “rb bertomeu” beco F1/ASF

 

MINIMUM  PROFIT    =     2,19   Euro/MWhe

 

Prices as of January/2017

We will be very pleased to make a personalized economical study based on your plant's characteristics, with the data provided by you, where we will demonstrate the high profitability of the addtive "rb bertomeu" beco F1/ASF.
Contact us on rbbertomeu@rbbertomeu.com.


 C-   PROFITS VERIFICATION TIME

 

The study "RB2.- Savings after using the "rb bertomeu" beco F1/ASF additive for heavy fuel oil. Description and normal verification time periods" shows the approximate time necessary to verify the accomplishment of both the general benefits and economical profits described in this document.


 

 


© rb bertomeu, S.L.  -   Pol. Ind. Fondo de Llitera, Par. 82-83  - E-22520 Fraga, Huesca (Spain)

Tel. +34 974 47 48 04  /  +34 638 33 55 33

 www.rbbertomeu.es - rbbertomeu@rbbertomeu.es